Luxury / news
Dior holiday animation drawss AI accusations as director defends hand-drawn method
A festive short film released by Dior has prompted social media users and press commentators to accuse the house of using artificial intelligence, claims the brand and its director reject. The dispute has centred on the animation's production technique and a character's six-fingered hand.
The film was made for Dior under creative director Jonathan Anderson, with the animation directed by Sylvain Chomet. Dior has presented the project as traditionally produced, and Chomet addressed the method in a video the house published across its social channels, including Instagram.
"Technically, we work just like in the 1940s, it is the same, it is the same technique," Chomet said in that video. Dior's press material likewise stressed the craft behind the film, comparing the artist's work to that of its haute couture ateliers, where, it said, long hours and precision produce a beauty that appears effortless.
Critics online were unconvinced. Commenters described the film as "falsely traditional", and some applied the term "slop", used for mass-produced AI content considered soulless and low in quality. Others singled out the drawing of a six-fingered hand on one of the characters as evidence that generative tools had been involved.
Chomet answered that point in an interview with Variety, explaining that the extra digit was a device to convey movement. "It is a movement where the hand fans out," he said. "In this type of drawing, you might see six or seven fingers to suggest motion."
Dior has continued to frame the project around artisanal production, while the debate over how the animation was made has played out in press coverage and across social platforms over recent days.